Consumer Watchdog filed comments urging Commissioner Matthew Baker to withdraw the proposed decision and return it to the Administrative Law Judges. It also asked the Commission to rule first on a Public Advocates Office motion concerning what it called an “incomplete record,” and to require PG&E to identify the projects it is deferring before approving an increase. The Commission was scheduled to vote on the proposal Thursday.
“Ratepayers shouldn't get a bill before the utilities are forced to justify what ratepayers are getting for that money,” said Jamie Court, Consumer Watchdog’s president. He said the proposed decision does not account for PG&E’s pullback from its planned infrastructure spending.
PG&E announced on Sept. 2 that it would defer about $2 billion in planned 2027 investment, reducing its borrowing needs by the same amount. Its parent company projected 2027 earnings of $1.78 to $1.82 per share, compared with $1.64 to $1.66 in 2026. PG&E filings also cite 10.6% earnings-per-share growth in 2024 and a 65% three-year return to shareholders. The Public Advocates Office said PG&E had indicated it could fund critical safety work partly by “retaining earnings to re-invest in the company.”
The proposed decision says PG&E faces no financial emergency. It argues that collecting money earlier could save customers an estimated $13.6 million to $21.0 million in interest, based on the utility carrying out its original spending forecast. Consumer Watchdog argues that the $2 billion deferral undermines that assumption.
In an Oct. 23 motion, the Public Advocates Office said setting rates on an incomplete record would be “unjust and unreasonable.” It said PG&E had not identified which forecast projects would be reduced or eliminated, and that the utility was still evaluating which programs to defer. Consumer Watchdog says the proposed decision does not address the deferral, PG&E’s strategic review or the pending motion. It argues that possible refunds later would not replace reviewing the figures before customers pay. Singleton Schreiber is co-counsel with Consumer Watchdog in the matter.



Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first!