Val Chmerkovskiy Calls Out AJ Pritchard’s Arrogance on DWTS

On his "Stepping on Toes" podcast, Chmerkovskiy warned that while Pritchard possesses an impressive competitive résumé, his dismissive demeanor toward partner Selena Hamilton poses a significant hurdle for his American television prospects. During a recent challenge centered on personal storytelling, Pritchard chose to focus his routine on his own British Open Dance Championship win rather than incorporating Hamilton’s narrative. Chmerkovskiy labeled this choice a missed opportunity to connect, noting that the show demands more than technical excellence; it requires a partner who can foster an emotional bond with both their colleague and the audience.

The friction extends to rehearsal footage, where Pritchard’s curt teaching style has drawn scrutiny. Chmerkovskiy acknowledged that such methods might pass in rigid competitive dance circles, but cautioned that they translate poorly to the collaborative environment of a mainstream reality series. He suggested that Pritchard appears uncomfortable with the audition-like nature of the competition, potentially viewing the process as beneath his established status. Chmerkovskiy urged the former "Strictly Come Dancing" star to abandon his reliance on past pedigree, pointing out that other contestants hold similar achievements without the accompanying friction. Ultimately, the message to Pritchard remains clear: success in the American ballroom requires humility and a willingness to prove himself anew, rather than living in the shadow of previous titles.